Starting a Motion for Madden 11 (Link Included)

[ZAN]

[Only registered users can see links. ]

I motion that scouting report buying of any EAFL member is illegal in EAFL leagues...

I Peyton ZANning I

[The Masta Ace]

No support from me on this one Zan...it doesn't show plays ran, just tendencies...its a great idea to see how players play, but not what they actually do...makes people really gameplan, mix up their play calling...nothing wrong with this...

WWW.EAFLMADDEN.COM
Where the big boys play...

[ZAN]

I'm not really scared of being scouted. I just wanna put that disclaimer down. I've run some exotic ish this season. I've run America's offense at times, as well. I try to run several looks a year....

I just think it's yet another EA cop out to bring the lower tiered players to the top without them putting in the same hard work that the top guys are doing.

I Peyton ZANning I

[Wingman300]

by season 3 of 2010 you see pretty much everything.... and you see copying(probably even earlier)... Really with being able to watch highlights you have all you need to copy.

For years on ps2 they had nice break downs. I think 360 had been doing it to a degree but you could eaisly find tendencies of your opponant.

this isnt much of anything to me.

0-16 Lions. Dare I say REPEAT?

EAFL - Where all Feuds are Settled on the Field

EAFL Staff.

[koampapapa]

this seems like one of those things that seems really cool at first, but when the actual game comes around, you find that it has no practical use. (right stick QB dodging in this year's game, for example)

edit: yea... the game tells you when you are being scouted... how stupid is that. completely defeats the purpose of it. obviously you call an original play, after knowing that.

EAFL-PS3 Co-Commissioner

EAFL Record: 173-97 (including 10-7 playoff)
18 seasons, 2 SB Rings, 9 playoff appearances.
EAFL PS3 - Season XIX - New York Giants - 10-6
TEAM GRYFFINDOR
Trophy King Madden 2010

---

Last edited by koampapapa; 06-02-2010 at 07:52 PM.

[Chubby Giangio™]

I see no problem with it.

Call me at 732-501-1844

[KOACHK]

Like some others already said in this thread; scouting reports aren't new at all to Madden; it's just that this version can be used during a game. It's nice to see what tendencies your opponents have, but players are still ultimately responsible for having the right scheme/plays to stop/contain what's coming. More advanced players will obviously "adjust to the adjustment" made by their opponents scouting them, and that's when the chess game starts; each and every game that's played is it's own entity.

KOACHK
*COMPETE4EVER OWNER
COMPETE4EVER: http://www.compete4ever.com
"I can accept failure, but I can't accept not trying."
-Michael Jordan

[Bad Wane]

YEa dont mind this at all, wont change the game much really.

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able, and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God.

- Epicurus

[ImUrDaddy84]

IF U SEE SUM 1 DOING CURL ROUTES ALOT, UR GONNA CHANGE UR D.....DO U REALLY NEED MADDEN TO TELL U HES CURLING?

AGREED, THIS WILL B A USELESS FEATURE, NOT PRACTICAL, WHATEVER

IF U CANT SEE WHATS HAPPENING IN THE GAME TO THE POINT U NEED THIS FEATURE U PROB WERENT EVER GONNA WIN THE GAME ANYHOW

PS3 SithLordXIII & ImUrDaddy84
X360 SithLordXIII

[Wingman300]

Originally Posted by ImUrDaddy84

IF U SEE SUM 1 DOING CURL ROUTES ALOT, UR GONNA CHANGE UR D.....DO U REALLY NEED MADDEN TO TELL U HES CURLING?

AGREED, THIS WILL B A USELESS FEATURE, NOT PRACTICAL, WHATEVER

IF U CANT SEE WHATS HAPPENING IN THE GAME TO THE POINT U NEED THIS FEATURE U PROB WERENT EVER GONNA WIN THE GAME ANYHOW

exactly

0-16 Lions. Dare I say REPEAT?

EAFL - Where all Feuds are Settled on the Field

EAFL Staff.

[Sangrado]

lol yeah this is basically for middle school kids who dont know anything about football and cant tell that your throwing to just 2 guys the whole game or whatever. If you really think about it, if people were to actually enter in all of there stats for league games, you would have your scouting report right there lol. For example if you do any research on me this season in the majors, then you know im running with DeAngelo 80-90% of the game lol its up to you to figure out how to stop it and for me to switch up my game once I see you make the adjustment.

in short, the feature wont matter for players with common sense

EAFL-360/EAFL-NCAA - DiRtY BuRn3r



Who DAT? BRENT GRIMES! ^^99 Ups^^
2009 Stats: 66 Tkls, 13 Pass Def, 6 INTs

[Wingman300]

Originally Posted by Sangrado

lol yeah this is basically for middle school kids who dont know anything about football and cant tell that your throwing to just 2 guys the whole game or whatever. If you really think about it, if people were to actually enter in all of there stats for league games, you would have your scouting report right there lol. For example if you do any research on me this season in the majors, then you know im running with DeAngelo 80-90% of the game lol its up to you to figure out how to stop it and for me to switch up my game once I see you make the adjustment.

in short, the feature wont matter for players with common sense

San no one has to look at your stats to guess that lol. (if they have ever played you)

0-16 Lions. Dare I say REPEAT?

EAFL - Where all Feuds are Settled on the Field

EAFL Staff.

[Sangrado]

Originally Posted by Wingman300

San no one has to look at your stats to guess that lol. (if they have ever played you)

lol yeah i know but it was first thing I could think of as an example haha since my first season in the majors on 08', when i went for 2000yds+ with LJ everyone knows i run the ball lol

EAFL-360/EAFL-NCAA - DiRtY BuRn3r



Who DAT? BRENT GRIMES! ^^99 Ups^^
2009 Stats: 66 Tkls, 13 Pass Def, 6 INTs

[Wingman300]

one of the hardest guys to stop at it also. Cant wait for 2011

0-16 Lions. Dare I say REPEAT?

EAFL - Where all Feuds are Settled on the Field

EAFL Staff.